An analysis proof of the hall marriage theorem mathoverflow. You are asked to show that all ranks can be matched by selections of piles. A graph g has a 1factor if and only if qgs jsj for all s vg, where qgs is the number of odd components of the graph gs. Norman biggs, discrete mathematics all these books, as well as all tutorial sheets and solutions, will be available in mathematicsphysics library on short loan. E from v 1 to v 2 is a set of m jv 1jindependent edges in g. Dilworths theorem states that given any finite partially ordered set, the size of any largest antichain is equal to the size of. For the if direction, let g be bipartite with bipartition a. Mathematics for computer science eric lehman and tom leighton. Combinatorial theorems via flows week 2 mathcamp 2011 last class, we proved the fordfulkerson minflow maxcut theorem, which said the following. Note that there is a polynomialtime algorithm which either. Robin wilson and john watkins, graphs an introductory approach. The proposition that a family of n subsets of a set s with n elements is a system. Take a cycle c n, and consider its line graph lc n.
For, if there are fewer boys the marriage condition fails. If there is a matching of size jaj, then this matching covers a and we are. That is to say, i hall s marriage condition holds for a bipartite graph, then a complete matching exists for that graph. Halls marriage theorem a family s of finite sets has a transversal if and only if s satisfies the marriage condition. The standard example of an application of the marriage theorem is to imagine two groups. Halls theorem let g be a bipartite graph with vertex sets v 1 and v 2 and edge set e. A bipartite graph g with vertex sets v 1 and v 2 contains a complete matching from v 1 to v 2 if and only if it satis es halls condition j sj jsjfor every s.
A common generalization of halls theorem and vizings edge. The marriage theorem, as credited to philip hall 7, gives the necessary and su. Then the maximum value of a ow is equal to the minimum value of a cut. Derive the marriage theorem halls theorem from uttest theorem. Marriage theorem article about marriage theorem by the free. In this paper we prove a generalized version of halls theorem for hypergraphs. For example, consider the graph below where x a,b,c and y 7. Theorem 1 a family of sets has a sdr if and only if it satis. Halls condition is both sufficient and necessary for a complete match. Mengers theorem 10 acknowledgments 12 references 12 1. This also gives a beautiful, completely new, topological proof of halls marriage. The graph theoretic formulation deals with a bipartite graph. If, for example, 5 of the women only have 4 men on their lists of potential mates, no marriage assignment is possible. We will use hall s marriage theorem to show that for any m, m, m, an m m mregular bipartite graph has a perfect matching.
A common generalization of halls theorem and vizings. If such a matrix exists then some r girls can marry only n s boys outside the submatrix. Each vertex has m m m neighbors, so the total number of edges coming out from p p p is p m. First, we observe that halls condition is clearly necessary. The following result is known as phillip halls marriage theorem. In mathematics, halls marriage theorem, proved by philip hall 1935, is a theorem with two. Strictly speaking, the proof below does not require the sets of boys and girls to be equipotent. Consider a set p p p of size p p p vertices from one side of the bipartition. Halls marriage theorem and hamiltonian cycles in graphs lionel levine may, 2001 if s is a set of vertices in a graph g, let ds be the number of vertices in g adjacent to at least one member of s. I stumbled upon this page in wikipedia about hall s marriage theorem. Halls marriage theorem gives conditions on when the vertices of a bipartite graph can be split into pairs of vertices corresponding to disjoint edges such that every vertex in the smaller class is accounted for. B, every matching is obviously of size at most jaj. Then we discuss three example problems, followed by a problem set.
In mathematics, halls marriage theorem, proved by philip hall, is a theorem with two equivalent formulations. I know it should be similar to the prove of halls marriage theorem by induction. What are some interesting applications of halls marriage. This condition is necessary, but it too fails to be sufficient for example, consider the. A classical result in graph theory, halls theorem, is that this is the only case in which a perfect matching does not exist. And luckily for the yenta, the marriage problem was solved in 1935, by mathematician philip hall see 6. Its been a while since my last blog post one reason being that i recently got married. In honor of that occasion, and my return to math blogging, here is a post on halls marriage theorem consider the following game of solitaire. This theorem asserts that every magic square r of weight d is the sum of d permutation matrices. As another example, consider the following problem whose solution becomes much simpler with halls marriage theorem in hand. Theorem 1 suppose that g is a graph with source and sink nodes s. Halls theorem gives a nice characterization of when such a matching exists. Latin squares could be used by dating services to organize meetings between a number n of girls and the same number n of boys.
It provides a necessary and su cient condition for the ability of selecting distinct. The sets v iand v o in this partition will be referred to as the input set. If an internal link led you here, you may wish to change the link to point directly to the intended article. F has a system of distinct repre sentatives abbreviated by sdr if it is possible to choose an element from each member of f so that all chosen elements are distinct. I stumbled upon this page in wikipedia about halls marriage theorem. Hall s marriage condition is both necessary and su cient for the existence of a complete match in a bipartite graph. More precisely, let h be a kuniform kpartite hypergraph with some ordering on parts as v1,v2. Hall s marriage theorem carl joshua quines figure 5. Pdf a marriage theorem basedalgorithm for solving sudoku. Halls marriage theorem is a result in combinatorics that specifies when distinct elements can be chosen from a collection of overlapping finite sets. The combinatorial formulation deals with a collection of finite sets. Looking at figure 3 we can see that this graph does not meet the marriage condition. Halls marriage theorem and hamiltonian cycles in graphs. The dating service is faced now with the task of arranging marriages so as to satisfy each girl preferences.
If g is finite and unmatchable, then, by theorem 5. Pdf on oct 1, 2015, ricardo soto and others published a marriage theorem basedalgorithm for solving. The marriage condition and the marriage theorem are due to the english mathematician philip hall 1935. Halls theorem will certainly give you the result you need, in either of two ways. If the sizes of the vertex classes are equal, then the matching naturally induces a bijection between the classes, and such a matching is. To prove that it is also su cient, we use induction on m. A solution to the marriage problem exists i each subset of k.
A, let ns denote the set of vertices necessarily in b which are adjacent to at least one vertex in s. To get that result directly from hall you need to show that every subset of the ranks spans at least as many piles. Applications of halls marriage theorem brilliant math. Anup rao 1 halls theorem in an undirected graph, a matching is a set of disjoint edges. A generalization of halls theorem for kuniform kpartite hypergraphs reza jafarpourgolzari abstract. A 2a n asystem of distinct representativessdr is a choice of a i 2a i for all i where a i 6 a j for i 6 j when can we pick an sdr. We define matchings and discuss halls marriage theorem. A family a i i2b of nite sets has a system of distinct representatives i it satis es the marriage. If the sizes of the vertex classes are equal, then the. Halls theorem 1 definitions 2 halls theorem cmu math. In mathematics, halls marriage theorem, proved by philip hall 1935, is a theorem with two equivalent formulations. The hall marriage theorem ewa romanowicz university of bialystok adam grabowski1 university of bialystok summary.
Garg department of electrical and computer engineering university of texas at austin austin, tx 787121084. Combining proposition 2, theorem 7 and lemma 8 we deduce the following. Marriage theorem article about marriage theorem by the. Halls marriage theorem eventually almost everywhere. R such that jlj jrjhas a perfect matching if and only if for every a l we have jaj jnaj.
In a complete matching m, each vertex in v 1 is incident with precisely one edge from m. A family a i i2b of sets satis es the marriage condition if for any k, the union of any k of the sets in the family has size at least k. A proof of tuttes theorem is given, which is then used to derive halls marriage theorem for bipartite graphs. Jun 25, 2014 thus halls conditions are satisfied and the marriage theorem implies that we can always win. For each woman, there is a subset of the men, any one of which she would happily marry. Pdf on oct 1, 2015, ricardo soto and others published a marriage theorem basedalgorithm for solving sudoku find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Hall s condition is both sufficient and necessary for a. Thus, by halls marriage theorem, there is a 1factor in g. A graph g is matchable if and only if 17g, s is espousable for every set of vertices s. At gil kalais blog, halls theorem for hypergraphs ron aharoni and penny haxell, 1999 is given, and then it says, ron aharoni and penny haxell described special type of triangulations, and then miraculously deduced their theorem from sperners lemma. Having met all the boys, each girl comes up with a list of boys she would not mind marrying. That halls condition is necessary for the presence of a matching is clear, as mentioned. Hall marriage theorem article about hall marriage theorem.
Dec 28, 20 halls marriage theorem gives conditions on when the vertices of a bipartite graph can be split into pairs of vertices corresponding to disjoint edges such that every vertex in the smaller class is accounted for. Introduction to lattice theory with computer science. We will use halls marriage theorem to show that for any m, m, m, an m m mregular bipartite graph has a perfect matching. I just know how hall follows from max flow min cut, but not the other way round and in fact, the other way it seems pretty unlikely to me. Systems of distinct representatives 1 sdrs and halls theorem. Mathematics for computer science eric lehman and tom. Halls condition we say that halls condition holds for x if and only if for all subsets s. Aug 20, 2017 for the love of physics walter lewin may 16, 2011 duration. Perfect matching in bipartite graphs a bipartite graph is a graph g v,e whose vertex set v may be partitioned into two disjoint set v i,v o in such a way that every edge e. Using menger s theorem there are independent paths, giving a matching in. Couplings are a proof technique used in probability theory, that can. Since r n s, there are just too few boys to satisfy all r girls. Since a subgraph of a bipartite graph is bipartite, a bipartite graph cannot.
This has traditionally been called the marriage theorem because of the possible interpretation. Combining these matchings gives a matching from v1 to. A solution to the marriage problem exists i each subset of k girls in g collectively knows at least k boys in b, for 1 k m. Hall s theorem states that an sdr exists if and only if for any number i of the women for i equal to one up to the total number of women the lumping together of the men on the lists of the i women contains at least i men. There are many different proofs of this theorem, so we do not give one here. It gives a necessary and sufficient condition for being able to select a distinct element from each set. For the love of physics walter lewin may 16, 2011 duration. So we cant make everyone happy, because at least one of these women will be sad. The proposition that a family of n subsets of a set s with n elements is a system of distinct representatives for s if any k of the subsets, k 1, 2, n, together contain at least k distinct elements. Then, a has a perfect matching to b if and only if ns. Any reference for why halls theorem is equivalent to the max flow min cut theorem.
99 726 1014 1417 628 499 1489 1172 776 126 1066 867 719 732 1447 1115 1036 1172 477 1476 1042 174 1253 707 1329 1303 1394 81 1110 583 550 929 10 352 540 1136 1206 396 1133